Play Prime World
Play Prime World
Image of Critical Thinking: Creative Control in Game Development

The controversy over Mass Effect 3's ending is long-since dead and gone, but the lessons learned from it - both by fans and by developers - still resonate within the community even now, more than a full year after the fact. For those of you who need a bit of a refresher, things kind of went something like this: Mass Effect 3's ending was rushed and awful. Fans expressed outrage that it was rushed and awful, and demanded that Bioware changed it. After one of the biggest media frenzies seen in the games industry, Bioware eventually acceded to its players. 

Oddly enough, this caused even further polarization throughout the community. There were many who claimed that changing the ending was a mistake - that, as a creator and artist, Bioware had a responsibility to ensure the artistic integrity of their title. Changing the ending simply because the fans demanded it was an insult, and represented a failure on the part of Bioware to stand their ground and stick to their guns. Those who opposed the extended cut included in their numbers gamers, journalists, and even developers and designers. 

"It's not about what ending we get," tweeted one aspiring game designer to Kotaku, "it's about the total disrespect and destruction of the artistic integrity of gaming's best." 


"Imagine we lived in a world where artists regularly changed their art based on audience demands." wrote Gamespot's Laura Parker. "Imagine Monet repainting Water Lilies in black and white because people objected to color. Imagine Salman Rushdie trashing The Satanic Verses because people objected to its implications. The very idea of allowing any work of art to be changed because someone, somewhere didn't like it would render all art meaningless." 

The arguments seem very clear-cut, no? If video games - as we've maintained for well over a decade now - are well and truly art, then does not any change made to said games on the behalf of anyone - be it fans, publishers, or critics -somehow make their position less legitimate? Does not Bioware's decision somehow undercut their title's status as a work of art; their status as artists? 

The short answer is "no." 

The truth is, creative control works a little differently in the medium of gaming. Games aren't static, unchanging modes of entertainment. A game isn't a painting, or a movie, or a novel. A game is an experience; a mercurial, ever-changing  represents a conversation between player and developer; a dialogue between creator and consumer. Games are art; yes, but at the same time,  they're something more; a player will generally engage with a game like Mass Effect to a much greater degree than they would with another product.   

Further, we cannot forget that games are ultimately commodities, even if they can be considered artistic ones.  As with any other product, if a customer has a problem with that product - if they have a concern with how something works - they can take their complaints back to the original developer. If enough people complain, the developer might be forced to change that product. It's the same deal with games: changing how a game ends because of a fan outcry doesn't somehow make it less legitimate as a work of art.

Quite the contrary, actually: the simple fact that the fans are willing to cause such a stink means that they were drawn in and engaged. They loved the experience enough that when it ended in a less-than-satisfactory manner, they rose up.

Finally, let's talk about logistics. See, there was a point, years ago, when developers would listen to fan input between iterations of their franchises, and adjust according to what they heard. Now, with new and more modern methods of distribution, developers are equipped with the  Developers can adjust their titles in real-time. 

In short, due to their unique position, games are a malleable art form. They can be shaped and reshaped, molded by both gamer and developer; and still retain everything that made them art in the first place. 

Do developers still have the final say in how their product turns out; full creative control over what they do with their games? Most definitely. At the same time, they ignore input from their players at their own peril. After all, these are the people who are going to be playing the title - one would assume that they know what they want, no? Ultimately, it's up to the development staff to decide where the line is drawn, to determine when they're going to say no to their fans. And that's exactly how it should be. 

Anyway, that's enough rambling for today. Next week, we're going to delve into the idea of a final boss - and whether or not it's necessary for a satisfactory video game narrative. Until then, keep exploring. 
 



Similar Posts
  • HyperX Cloud Pro Gaming Headset
    HyperX Cloud Pro Gaming Headset

    How does the new HyperX Cloud Pro Gaming Headset from Kingston stack up against the competition?

  • Eight of The Most Memorable MMO Dungeons Ever Designed
    Eight of The Most Memorable MMO Dungeons Ever Designed

    Dungeons are a staple of the MMO genre; large-scale challenges requiring co-operation and co-ordination between anywhere from five to a few hundred players to adequately complete. Of course, not all are created equal, and some stand head and shoulders above their peers. Today, I'd like to tip my hat to those few legends, those instances that'll stick with us for years to come as shining examples of how to do dungeons right.

  • Ten Of The Best MMORPG Songs Ever Heard
    Ten Of The Best MMORPG Songs Ever Heard

    In many ways, an MMO is only as good as its music. Many of the best and most memorable moments in an MMO invariably have a song associated with them; a piece of music which brings the memories flooding back the moment it reaches one's ears. Today, I'd like to pay homage to some of those songs - and some of those moments. Here, for your listening pleasure (and in no particular order, I assure you) is a list of some of the best songs ever heard in an MMO.

  • Facebook's Purchase Of Oculus VR Isn't The End Of The World
    Facebook's Purchase Of Oculus VR Isn't The End Of The World

    For those of you who've been living under a rock, Facebook recently purchased Oculus VR to the tune of $2 billion. Understandably, backers and developers alike were rather unimpressed, calling it a betrayal. As for me? I've never been more excited.

  • Seven Of The Worst Things You Can Say In League
    Seven Of The Worst Things You Can Say In League

    If you've played league, you've probably encountered at least one toxic player. If you haven't, there's a good chance that YOU are the toxic one. Don't believe me? Ask yourself if you've ever said any of the following...

  • Six Reasons You Should Be Playing Dark Souls II
    Six Reasons You Should Be Playing Dark Souls II

    I've been playing a lot of Dark Souls II lately - and you should be too. Say what you will about the game's flaws, it's still arguably one of the best action RPGs released in the past several years. If you're up for a bit of a challenge, it's well worth the buy. Don't believe me? Let's talk, then.

  • Eight Reasons The Elder Scrolls Online Will Be Awesome
    Eight Reasons The Elder Scrolls Online Will Be Awesome

    As you're all no doubt aware, The Elder Scrolls Online - currently in open beta - will be launching in a few months or so. In light of both the new release date and all the hype surfacing around it, I've decided that, over the next two weeks, I'll be looking at all the reasons to look forward to it...and all the reasons we shouldn't.

  • League of Legends or DOTA 2?
    League of Legends or DOTA 2?

    The debate between Dota 2 and League of Legends has been raging almost since the two games were first released. But which game is REALLY the superior of the two?

  • Ten Fictional Settings That'd Make For Awesome MMOs
    Ten Fictional Settings That'd Make For Awesome MMOs

    Let's look at a few settings, worlds, and stories I'd love to see made into MMOs. I'm sure you'll agree, all the entries on this list have the potential to be downright awesome.

  • MMO Year In Review: 5 of 2013's Biggest Dick Moves
    MMO Year In Review: 5 of 2013's Biggest Dick Moves

    People are dicks - particularly on the Internet. While that shouldn't come as any great surprise, occasionally we come across someone whose level of sheer dickery reaches legendary proportions. As we move into 2014, let's take a look at a few such individuals from the previous year.


comments powered by Disqus