Play Prime World
Play Prime World
Image of Critical Thinking: Player Agency and the Illusion of Choice

Last week, I examined the concept of branching narrative in the context of gaming. Working from an interview with TellTale Games and using The Walking Dead as an example, I came to the conclusion that, ultimately,  the choices themselves don't matter. What's truly important is that you make your players invest themselves in the dilemmas you've presented them; make them think and feel and agonize over which choice is the right one. If you can't do this, it doesn't matter how many different paths your story gives the players - they aren't going to care. 

Emotional investment is only part of the equation, however. Once you've got the players caring about their choices, you have to show them that those choices actually made a difference. Perhaps even more vital to any good narrative is player agency: essentially, allowing the player's actions to have a real, noticeable impact on the world around them - and demonstrating to them that impact. 


Essentially, you need to show them what they've done to shape their environment.  You need to present them with consequences. 

If you fail to accomplish this, you'd best ready yourself for the backlash. Players who were emotionally invested in the plot will feel as though their investment was cheapened, and will more than likely disconnect from your title - and any future titles you create. It's fairly easy to see why, truth be told: after creating a narrative in which they're truly engrossed, characters they actually care about, and a series of choices that actually make them think...you run roughshod over everything they've accomplished. You inform them - in no uncertain terms - that their choices ultimately don't matter, and that all that they've invested was a waste of energy. 

Not to beat a dead horse, but the ending of Mass Effect 3 was a prime example. Rather than enabling the player to see the universe they shaped, rather than showing them what really transpired as a result of their decision, Bioware treated the players to a woefully-short, incredibly shoddy cutscene which was virtually the same no matter what choice they made. Several years of gameplay, several years spent with a cast of beloved characters down into about thirty seconds. The players were given a choice, yes; but it was ultimately a hollow one, with none of the emotional weight and care that they'd come to expect.  

The fury of Mass Effect fans was absolutely legendary, and rose to such a fever pitch that Bioware, in an effort to placate fans, released an extended ending. The issue was that players didn't feel that the decisions they'd made were given their due - they didn't get a chance to see the weight of their choices, the impact they'd had upon the fate and future of a universe they'd come to know and love. They felt that all the attachment they'd developed to the series had been entirely disregarded - which, in a sense, was completely true. 

So how does one avoid such a pitfall as this? How does one keep a coherent narrative while at the same time ensuring that players can exert a very real influence on the world around them? 

Now, as we've already established, true choice is virtually impossible in the context of a video game narrative. Barring some incredible, world-changing technological advancement, there will always need to be guardrails: there will always need to be a set path hiding somewhere in a story. The trick lies in providing players with the illusion of choice. 

You need to make players feel as though they are making real choices, with real consequences. It doesn't actually have to lie in allowing the player to decide how a story ends. The Walking Dead game essentially had the same basic ending no matter what the player did - yet it stands as a shining example of player agency in gaming. Why? 

Because players could actively shape the plot in small ways, even if they couldn't decide exactly where it was going. 

Setting something like this up is easier said than done, and the illusion of choice is a fragile one; easily broken along with a player's suspension of disbelief. Depending on how you've established your players are capable of shaping your world, a disconnect can occur in one of three ways:  

  1. If the players can't make a choice which would seem the obvious one for any sane,stable human being.
  2. If events will clearly proceed in the same fashion no matter what the player does, even though they're led to expect more - their choices literally have as much impact on the plot as whether or not their character is wearing a hat. 
  3. If they're given choices, but there's either no demonstrable weight to the choices or they never get to see them satisfactorily resolved. The choices literally just exist to advance the story, without any real consequences one way or the other.  


Essentially, the illusion is broken when a choice is handled in a ham-handed fashion which makes it clear that any agency the players have been given over your world - and your story - is a farce. The players disconnect when the choices they're given don't mesh with the choices they've expected.  If you wish to avoid this, there's really only one way to do it: a combination of good writing and foresight. 

In any case,  I've droned on enough for now. Next week, we're going to delve into creative control in the game development scene. Until then, have a good one. 



Similar Posts
  • Eight of The Most Memorable MMO Dungeons Ever Designed
    Eight of The Most Memorable MMO Dungeons Ever Designed

    Dungeons are a staple of the MMO genre; large-scale challenges requiring co-operation and co-ordination between anywhere from five to a few hundred players to adequately complete. Of course, not all are created equal, and some stand head and shoulders above their peers. Today, I'd like to tip my hat to those few legends, those instances that'll stick with us for years to come as shining examples of how to do dungeons right.

  • Ten Of The Best MMORPG Songs Ever Heard
    Ten Of The Best MMORPG Songs Ever Heard

    In many ways, an MMO is only as good as its music. Many of the best and most memorable moments in an MMO invariably have a song associated with them; a piece of music which brings the memories flooding back the moment it reaches one's ears. Today, I'd like to pay homage to some of those songs - and some of those moments. Here, for your listening pleasure (and in no particular order, I assure you) is a list of some of the best songs ever heard in an MMO.

  • Facebook's Purchase Of Oculus VR Isn't The End Of The World
    Facebook's Purchase Of Oculus VR Isn't The End Of The World

    For those of you who've been living under a rock, Facebook recently purchased Oculus VR to the tune of $2 billion. Understandably, backers and developers alike were rather unimpressed, calling it a betrayal. As for me? I've never been more excited.

  • Seven Of The Worst Things You Can Say In League
    Seven Of The Worst Things You Can Say In League

    If you've played league, you've probably encountered at least one toxic player. If you haven't, there's a good chance that YOU are the toxic one. Don't believe me? Ask yourself if you've ever said any of the following...

  • Six Reasons You Should Be Playing Dark Souls II
    Six Reasons You Should Be Playing Dark Souls II

    I've been playing a lot of Dark Souls II lately - and you should be too. Say what you will about the game's flaws, it's still arguably one of the best action RPGs released in the past several years. If you're up for a bit of a challenge, it's well worth the buy. Don't believe me? Let's talk, then.

  • Eight Reasons The Elder Scrolls Online Will Be Awesome
    Eight Reasons The Elder Scrolls Online Will Be Awesome

    As you're all no doubt aware, The Elder Scrolls Online - currently in open beta - will be launching in a few months or so. In light of both the new release date and all the hype surfacing around it, I've decided that, over the next two weeks, I'll be looking at all the reasons to look forward to it...and all the reasons we shouldn't.

  • League of Legends or DOTA 2?
    League of Legends or DOTA 2?

    The debate between Dota 2 and League of Legends has been raging almost since the two games were first released. But which game is REALLY the superior of the two?

  • Ten Fictional Settings That'd Make For Awesome MMOs
    Ten Fictional Settings That'd Make For Awesome MMOs

    Let's look at a few settings, worlds, and stories I'd love to see made into MMOs. I'm sure you'll agree, all the entries on this list have the potential to be downright awesome.

  • MMO Year In Review: 5 of 2013's Biggest Dick Moves
    MMO Year In Review: 5 of 2013's Biggest Dick Moves

    People are dicks - particularly on the Internet. While that shouldn't come as any great surprise, occasionally we come across someone whose level of sheer dickery reaches legendary proportions. As we move into 2014, let's take a look at a few such individuals from the previous year.

  • Censorship Spells Trouble for League of Legends Patcher
    Censorship Spells Trouble for League of Legends Patcher

    Internet filtering has been a hot button issue for the past several years. With the slow gutting of protective measures like Net Neutrality, and with governmental powers seeking an end to online anonymity, it's rather harrowing to see the slow progression of political and social policing of the internet. Recently, after about a year of lobbying, the United Kingdom enacted a piece of legislation that many have come to call the "UK Porn Filter." What the filter requires is for British ISP's to implement filters and controls, which are on by default, that will block access to "violent material," not imited to "extremist and terrorist related content," "anorexia and eating disorder websites," and "suicide related websites."


comments powered by Disqus