Play Prime World
Play Prime World
Image of Critical Thinking: On Branching Narrative

Last time, I mused a bit on the concept of linearity versus openness in gaming. Today, I'd like to continue that line of thought, with a look at narrative paths in game design. See, I was reading an article the other day - an interview with TellTale Games - where it was revealed that they almost cut Clementine from The Walking Dead. If you're among those who've played the game, I'm sure you'll agree that it would have been a catastrophic choice which would have resulted in one of the best features of the game - one of the game's sole driving factors - being absent.

It's actually not going too far to say that The Walking Dead wouldn't have been anywhere near as good without her. It simply wouldn't have been the same - there really would have been no emotional investiture. None of the choices would have carried the same weight, none of the consequences would have had the same impact. Without Clementine there to rely on Lee - on the player - for safety and protection,without her to look up to him; his choices would have seemed more about self-interest than anything.  

For a game that carries with it such heavy undertones of redemption, that would have been tragic.

But we're getting a bit off track. One of the main topics of this interview was the inherent danger in giving a player too many choices - in becoming obsessed with having an 'open' narrative. As I discussed last time, a truly open and free-choice game is virtually impossible. The medium simply doesn't allow for it. As a result, there needs to be a limit. There needs to be a narrative guardrail, of sorts. If you don't limit things, you eventually reach a point where you've become so obsessed with branches - so consumed with the idea of player agency - that you've diluted and sacrificed the integrity of your story. 
Telltale creative lead Jake Rodkin basically said as much in the interview. 

"I think with the idea of an interactive story it?s really, really easy to get fixated on branching the narrative just for the sake of having more branches," explained Rodkin." You can spend forever coming up with cool ways to branch a story and lose sight of what makes the choices that you?re branching have resonance in the first place, which is the context that?s built up before the choice is made?the reason that a player is actually making a choice. It turns out that you can branch your narrative all you want, and that doesn?t make your narrative any more meaningful if the act of actually making those choices have no meaning.?

That's what Clementine added to The Walking Dead more than anything: she gave the choices made by the player actual meaning. They weren't just a series of arbitrary decisions forced on Lee, nor were they simply added forks in a plot-driven railroad. The addition of a father-daughter dynamic to Lee's story caused the player to actually feel a connection to the narrative. They weren't simply tromping along the road, not bothering to look at the scenery and moving from one choice to the next- they were actually thinking about how each decision would impact Clementine, and whether or not she'd be harmed. 

In short, the players were actually invested in securing Clementine's well-being. 

That, I think, is what a lot of narratives lack these days, just as its what's lacking in the vast majority of moral choice systems: meaning and emotional investment. You can add all the little decisions you want, you can add a flashy karma meter and have NPCs respond to every move a character makes, but at the end of the day, if the player doesn't give a damn about their choices, none of this matters. 

If you just present a black-and-white choice to them and simply inform them that one path is good; the other, without explaining why - without making them care - it doesn't matter how deep and driven your story is, it doesn't matter how many choices you give your players, or how many dilemmas they have to soldier through. You can give them a million, billion choices, and they still aren't likely to pay your story much mind. If, however, you do something to make them care - if you get the emotionally invested - even a simple fork in the road can be one of the most memorable, meaningful choices they'll ever make. 

Of course, you'll also have to show them their choices actually matter, too. We'll discuss that next week. I'll see you fine folks then. 

Similar Posts
  • HyperX Cloud Pro Gaming Headset
    HyperX Cloud Pro Gaming Headset

    How does the new HyperX Cloud Pro Gaming Headset from Kingston stack up against the competition?

  • Eight of The Most Memorable MMO Dungeons Ever Designed
    Eight of The Most Memorable MMO Dungeons Ever Designed

    Dungeons are a staple of the MMO genre; large-scale challenges requiring co-operation and co-ordination between anywhere from five to a few hundred players to adequately complete. Of course, not all are created equal, and some stand head and shoulders above their peers. Today, I'd like to tip my hat to those few legends, those instances that'll stick with us for years to come as shining examples of how to do dungeons right.

  • Ten Of The Best MMORPG Songs Ever Heard
    Ten Of The Best MMORPG Songs Ever Heard

    In many ways, an MMO is only as good as its music. Many of the best and most memorable moments in an MMO invariably have a song associated with them; a piece of music which brings the memories flooding back the moment it reaches one's ears. Today, I'd like to pay homage to some of those songs - and some of those moments. Here, for your listening pleasure (and in no particular order, I assure you) is a list of some of the best songs ever heard in an MMO.

  • Facebook's Purchase Of Oculus VR Isn't The End Of The World
    Facebook's Purchase Of Oculus VR Isn't The End Of The World

    For those of you who've been living under a rock, Facebook recently purchased Oculus VR to the tune of $2 billion. Understandably, backers and developers alike were rather unimpressed, calling it a betrayal. As for me? I've never been more excited.

  • Seven Of The Worst Things You Can Say In League
    Seven Of The Worst Things You Can Say In League

    If you've played league, you've probably encountered at least one toxic player. If you haven't, there's a good chance that YOU are the toxic one. Don't believe me? Ask yourself if you've ever said any of the following...

  • Six Reasons You Should Be Playing Dark Souls II
    Six Reasons You Should Be Playing Dark Souls II

    I've been playing a lot of Dark Souls II lately - and you should be too. Say what you will about the game's flaws, it's still arguably one of the best action RPGs released in the past several years. If you're up for a bit of a challenge, it's well worth the buy. Don't believe me? Let's talk, then.

  • Eight Reasons The Elder Scrolls Online Will Be Awesome
    Eight Reasons The Elder Scrolls Online Will Be Awesome

    As you're all no doubt aware, The Elder Scrolls Online - currently in open beta - will be launching in a few months or so. In light of both the new release date and all the hype surfacing around it, I've decided that, over the next two weeks, I'll be looking at all the reasons to look forward to it...and all the reasons we shouldn't.

  • League of Legends or DOTA 2?
    League of Legends or DOTA 2?

    The debate between Dota 2 and League of Legends has been raging almost since the two games were first released. But which game is REALLY the superior of the two?

  • Ten Fictional Settings That'd Make For Awesome MMOs
    Ten Fictional Settings That'd Make For Awesome MMOs

    Let's look at a few settings, worlds, and stories I'd love to see made into MMOs. I'm sure you'll agree, all the entries on this list have the potential to be downright awesome.

  • MMO Year In Review: 5 of 2013's Biggest Dick Moves
    MMO Year In Review: 5 of 2013's Biggest Dick Moves

    People are dicks - particularly on the Internet. While that shouldn't come as any great surprise, occasionally we come across someone whose level of sheer dickery reaches legendary proportions. As we move into 2014, let's take a look at a few such individuals from the previous year.

comments powered by Disqus